In Vietnam Even Bears Face Eviction


Across Southeast Asia land grabbing has become an enormous issue. In Vietnam, a showdown is looming between animal rights activists and the government, which is planning to evict a wildlife sanctuary from a national park used to house bears rescued from illegal bile farms.

Practitioners of traditional Asian medicine claim bear bile is effective as an anti-inflammatory in the treatment of fever and can improve eyesight while healing an assortment of ailments. The practice is barbaric with the bile harvested through a catheter or a needle which is inserted into the bile duct of the bear held captive in small cages often for years at a time.

Hoping to end bile farming, Hong Kong-based Animals Asia initially constructed the sanctuary on six hectares of land in Vinh Phuc province in the Red River Delta region of northern Vietnam after reaching an agreement with the government more than four years ago.

As a result, Animals Asia invested more than U.S. $2 million in building and infrastructure while employing more than 77 local Vietnamese staff and importantly 104 bears have been given a home and creature comforts after spending up to 30 years in captivity.

But Animals Asia now says the terms of that deal have changed and accused Tam Do National Park director Do Dinh Tien of lobbying the Ministry of Defense to evict the sanctuary for personal reasons, construction of a hotel through a company with alleged business ties to his daughter.
It also says Tien had undertaken “an aggressive campaign” by deliberately spreading misinformation in an attempt to block construction of a third outdoor enclosure, claiming that waste pollution from the rescue center was damaging the environment and the health of the local community.

An application was lodged to have the sanctuary closed but relevant ministries rejected the request. Animals Asia says the all powerful Defense Ministry was then approached and the land reclassified as a zone of national security importance.

Animals Asia was then told the Defense Ministry had subsequently issued the order to evict the sanctuary.

Tien has denied the accusations, says he is simply a junior person and adds claims that he was behind the eviction were nonsensical because he did not have any relatives or friends working in senior positions at the Defense Ministry.

Nevertheless, the eviction order stands.

Animals Asia has enlisted celebrity support of British comedians and actors Ricky Gervais and Stephen Fry who are sponsoring bears, narrating documentaries and are pushing their cause through social media networks.

It is believed that thousands of bears, including moon bears, Malayan sun bears and brown bears, are kept on bile farms in Vietnam where they are milked, despite the ban imposed by the Vietnamese government in 1992.

Under the law, people are still allowed to keep bears as pets or tourist attractions but owners often flout the ban with the practice still finding acceptance regardless of heavy fines.

In China, where bile farming is not illegal, Guizhentang Pharmaceutical, a firm that sells bile extracted from moon bears, was listed by the China Securities Regulatory Commission last year as a company seeking to make an initial public offering (IPO). The IPO was eventually withdrawn but only after animal rights activists highlighted the treatment by the company of 470 bears.

A final decision on the Vietnamese sanctuary now rests with Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung.

Jackie Sanchez
November 14, 2012 at 14:11

I hope these poor bears catch a break after all they have been through. We are their voice and must speak for them. Laws must be enforced to protect them. sanctions and boycotts must be put in place for governments and companies that allow animal cruelty.

Alex Dawson
November 11, 2012 at 23:29

Anyone who looks into the eyes above cannot have any other conviction than that of their freedom, happiness and well being above any human greed.
As the only species with a voice lets stand together and be heard.

November 11, 2012 at 08:33

The Bear Sanctuary could be promoted as a tourist attraction.
Personally I would visit places of hisorical interest, wildlife reserves and wilderness reserves when
visiting another country.

Peter O'Reehan
November 10, 2012 at 12:53

It seems to me that's what is most interesting about the situation, is that if a regime says they can take away land from a foreign investor, non-profit or commercial, without decent reason nor compensation, then why would anyone invest in Vietnam?  It's shooting yourself in the foot with a trident missile.  Surely this puts all future inward investment in jeopardy. 

Sue hart-Jackson
November 10, 2012 at 05:26

I am confident that the prime minister of the well respected country of vietnam will not allow this corruption to happen

November 9, 2012 at 22:57

Corrupt, selfish, dirty, SOB.  I hope he and his cronies rot in hell. 

Kate Walsh
November 9, 2012 at 21:29

Can only hope the Prime Minister makes the correct decision and does not side with these land grabbing, corrupt thieves. Let’s also actively raise awareness, protest against this vile vile practice of bear vile farming and support Jill Robinson in the fantastic job she, and all the workers do, at Animals Asia.

Share your thoughts

Your Name
Your Email
required, but not published
Your Comment

Sign up for our weekly newsletter
The Diplomat Brief