Burma: A Fragile Peace
Image Credit: Wikicommons

Burma: A Fragile Peace

0 Likes
8 comments

The red-carpet invitation extended to President Thein Sein to visit European capitals at the beginning of March has transformed Burma from pariah state into a new Asian partner, with the international community lavishing praise on the government’s tentative steps towards reform and ending the civil war.

But ethnic leaders and civil society groups inside Burma have painted a less rosy picture. They claim the peace process is undermined by ceasefire violations, land-grabbing by powerful businessmen and the government’s reluctance to discuss a political settlement.

By the end of 2012, many Western governments were impressed that most of the ethnic rebel armies holding sway in areas bordering Thailand and China had signed ceasefire agreements with the reformist-leaning government of President Thein Sein.

The retired general and president’s 11-day European tour included Norway, Finland, Austria and other EU countries, followed later in the month by a visit to New Zealand and Australia. He no doubt delighted his Austrian hosts at a Vienna press conference, assuring them of the complete success of his peace efforts at home.   

"There’s no more hostilities, no more fighting over the country, we have been able to end this armed conflict,” Thein Sein said at a joint press conference with Austrian President Heimilitarnz Fischer in Vienna on March 4.

Even as he spoke, however, in northern Burma military clashes were continuing in the Shan and in Kachin states. The Kachin National Organization responded to Thein Sein with a statement claiming, “The Burmese government is committing war crimes and preparing another big scale conflict while claiming 'peace' in Kachinland.”

Only a few weeks before Thein Sein’s European trip, government forces had launched attacks in Kachin state involving helicopters and artillery, with a ferocious assault on KIA rebel positions near the town of Laiza, inside a shrinking liberated zone adjacent to the Chinese border.

In repeated rounds of peace talks with Karen, Shan and Kachin groups, the government has refused calls for a demilitarization of the conflict zones. The shelling may be less frequent, but the guns have not fallen silent. Any celebration of peace is highly premature

The largest ethnic army, the Kachin Independence Army and its political wing, the Kachin Independence Organization met with the government for peace talks in the Chinese city of Ruili on March 11, but declined to sign a ceasefire agreement.

Comments
8

[...] is getting lots of trade offers, but it still is fighting minority groups, and its government is promoting land [...]

tocharian
April 5, 2013 at 00:35

That might nclude Suu Kyi, nowadays!

Sean F. Monahan
April 3, 2013 at 06:59

Not one mention of the Rohingya in this entire article. For shame.

[...] Burma: A Fragile Peace By Tom Fawthrop The Diplomat [...]

bangsatster
March 27, 2013 at 10:19

Burma should simply roll over and just allow historical excavators, treadure hunters and the U.S. military, or better, the Coalition Forces, to take over. Then, everything will be very fine and dandy. Heh, heh. Thanks, Diplomat.

Kim's Uncle
March 27, 2013 at 03:15

The only way to protect Burma’s independence is to fight China’s interference in Burma. Exposé any Burmese politicians who are in the payroll of china!

Nyan Myo Aung
March 26, 2013 at 16:35

In recent Union Parliament,a proposal for forming Constitutional Evaluation Committee or Commission has been approved by all representatives including ones from army and USDP. Now, all political forces are leading towards constitutional amendment,but I think dialogue and all-inclusiveness is very important to serves the interests of all stakeholders in amending constitution.

tocharian
March 26, 2013 at 13:12

The article says: "The largest ethnic army, the Kachin Independence Army"

This is not correct. The largest ethnic insurgent army in Burma is the United Wa State Army (UWSA) fully funded and armed by Peking. In fact UWSA is more or less a PLA proxy and China treats the region controlled by the UWSA as practically Chinese territory (same currency, power grid, phone lines etc.)

Anther monor error: "peace advocate Hla Muang Shwe" His name is Hla Maung Shwe.

The Burmese Parliament will review and revise the Nargis constitution before the 2015 election. The main purpose is to amend the clause that is preventing Suu Kyi from becoming president, which is the only thing she cares about. I predict that there will be no new Panglong. The MP's from the army (tatmadaw) and their civilian wing, the USDP would not go for that.

Share your thoughts

Your Name
required
Your Email
required, but not published
Your Comment
required

Newsletter
Sign up for our weekly newsletter
The Diplomat Brief