Unhappy with the prospect of essentially being force-fed genetically modified Golden Rice that packs an added vitamin-A punch, a group of 400 farmers in the Philippines recently stormed a field at a government research facility in Pili, in the province of Camarines Sur, and destroyed roughly 10 football fields’ (1,000 square meters) worth of the test crop.
The act of mass protest was motivated by the farmers’ collective disdain for genetically modified organisms (GMO), which they said have not yet been proven to be safe for consumption.
According to those who oppose the introduction of GMO crops to the Philippines – and elsewhere – the answer to malnutrition is not bioengineering, but alleviating poverty.Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.
The farmers worked not alone, but in concert with students, academics, and other members of the public under the umbrella of SIKWAL-GMO. “Golden Rice is not an answer to the country’s problem on hunger and malnutrition,” said Bert Autor, as quoted by the Philippine newspaper Remate. Autor added, “They were not able to control their emotional outburst” upon hearing the dangers of Golden Rice.
“The Golden Rice is a poison,” added a farmer named Willy Marbella who also serves as deputy secretary general of a group of agricultural activists called KMP (Peasant Movement of the Philippines).
Beau Baconguis, program manager for Greenpeace Southeast Asia in the Philippines conceded, “There is not enough safety testing done on any GM crops.”
Golden Rice is a GMO strain of rice developed in the 1990s by Ingo Potrykus of the Institute for Plant Sciences, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology and Peter Beyer of the University of Freiburg in Germany. The GMO crop is imbued with beta-carotene, a precursor of vitamin A that accounts for its yellow color.
The motivation for developing the strain of rice was to supplement diets in poverty stricken countries where starchy foods predominate. The New Scientist notes that every year, vitamin-A deficiency kills up to 2 million people and leads to blindness in 500,000 children worldwide. Golden Rice purportedly covers 60 percent of the required daily vitamin A intake.
A statement from the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) reads: “Farmers would be able to grow it like other rice and it won’t cost them any extra, and it would not cost consumers extra either. Golden Rice will be available to farmers and consumers only after it has been determined to be safe for humans, animals, and the environment and authorised for propagation and consumption by the appropriate regulatory authorities. Therefore, Golden Rice, if and when released, will be as safe as other rice.”
There are also business concerns at play. Regardless of whether they eliminate the crops that spring up, the risk of crosspollination exists. If this were to happen, the farmers would risk facing boycotts on their crops.
Bruce Tolentino, deputy director general of the IRRI, dismissed these concerns. “These are confined field trials,” Tolentino said. “They’re fenced. They’re covered by nets. They’re protected from rats and birds. And, we hoped, people.” Tolentino further pointed to evidence that rice generally self-pollinates and does not normally contaminate other crops.
In the wake of the event, the IRRI labeled the farmers “vandals” and proceeded to release a video singing the praises of GMO.
Vandals or not, the farmers’ concerns were not entirely unfounded. In June, unapproved GMO wheat was discovered sprouting from a field in Oregon this spring, which led to boycotts of U.S. wheat by Japan and South Korea.
Acknowledging the farmers’ concerns, Baconguis added, “I think that the farmers know what they want,” she said. “What they want is a safe environment that they can grow their crops in without fear of contamination and a subsequent boycott…This is playing with the lives of people when you are using Golden Rice to promote more GMOs in our food.”
Despite what went down in Pili last week, the Philippines is one of the first Asian nations to jump on the GMO bandwagon, including corn as well. On the other hand, the country has also turned down other GMO offerings, as seen in the ruling earlier this year that a GM eggplant known as Bt talong is unsafe for human consumption.