The Pulse

India’s Top Court Orders Review of All Curbs in Kashmir

Recent Features

The Pulse | Politics | South Asia

India’s Top Court Orders Review of All Curbs in Kashmir

The review includes the suspension of internet service in the region, which has been ongoing for months.

India’s Top Court Orders Review of All Curbs in Kashmir
Credit: AP Photo/Mukhtar Khan

India’s top court on Friday ordered the government to review all restrictions, including the suspension of internet service, in Indian-controlled Kashmir within a week, saying the measures amounted to abuse of power.

Defense attorney Vrinda Grover said the Supreme Court also directed the government to make public all orders imposing a lockdown in Kashmir in August after Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist-led government revoked the Muslim-majority region’s semi-autonomous status.

The court held that the internet shutdown impacted the freedom of press, which is part of freedom of speech and expression.

Ghulam Nabi Azad, a leader of the opposition Congress party, and Anuradha Bhasin, editor of The Kashmir Times, were the main petitioners in the case.

The Congress party said the court delivered the “first big jolt of 2020 to illegal activities of Modi’s government by stating the importance of the internet as a fundamental right.”

The people of Kashmir were waiting for this judgement, said Azad.

Ehsan Ali, a Kashmiri university student, said the court should have struck down government restrictions. “Even intention of restoring basic rights is sold to the people as a relief,” Ali said.

The decision to abolish Kashmir’s special status was accompanied by a extensive lockdown, with New Delhi sending tens of thousands of additional troops to the already heavily militarized region, imposing a sweeping curfew, arresting thousands and cutting virtually all communications.

Authorities have since eased several restrictions, lifted roadblocks and restored landlines and cellphone services. The internet, however, remains cut off.

Officials also have encouraged students to return to school and businesses to reopen, but top political leaders from the region continue to be under arrest or detention.

On January 1, authorities announced that internet service would be allowed in 80 state-run hospitals in the Kashmir valley.

The Press Trust of India news agency said the Supreme Court on Friday ordered the authorities to restore the internet to essential services like hospitals and educational institutions as they reviewed restrictions in the region.

Bhasin said the restrictions had crippled media outlets, essential services and even communications between families, bringing untold miseries to people.

Solicitor-General Tushar Mehta, who argued the government’s case, said authorities acted based on evidence from intelligence and the military that inflammatory material and speeches, and faked stories, photos and videos were being spread on social media.

Mehta had argued in the court that “modern terrorism relies heavily on the internet” and considers social media as its most effective weapon.

By Ashok Sharma for the Associated Press.