Japan White Paper Slams China Over Disputed Territory


Japan’s 2014 Ministry of Defense white paper was released on Tuesday, and regional territorial disputes figured heavily in the 505-page report. While North Korea was mentioned, most of the report’s findings focused on China and its growing military presence in the East and South China Seas. The overt focus on China could have an interesting effect on Japanese foreign and military policy, as the Cabinet of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe adopted the report on the same day. Abe has recently been pushing through multiple channels to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping, claiming that “his door is always open” to mend ties with the Chinese president. However, the Cabinet’s adoption of a normalized view on collective self-defense in late June makes this latest white paper more ominous than previous iterations.

The most incendiary portion of the new report states that China’s “dangerous acts” concerning its claims in the East China Sea could lead to “unintended consequences” for the region. In particular the report singled out the implementation of China’s new Air Defense Identification Zone (ADIZ) as a “profoundly dangerous act” that “raise[d] concerns over China’s future direction.” With regard to the South China Sea, Japan used language preferred by its chief ally the U.S. by stating that China’s actions were “incompatible with the existing international law” and that it was “attempting to alter the status quo by coercive measures.”

This is exactly the type of language that Japan and the U.S. used when confronting China at the Shangri-La Dialogue hosted by Singapore in May, after which Japanese/Sino relations reached another low point. The difference now is that the Abe government is well on its way to enshrining its new self-defense capabilities through proposed legislation in the Diet and by having the right included in the update to the Japanese-U.S. defense cooperation guidelines scheduled for the end of this year.

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

It is difficult to reconcile the government’s increasingly hawkish behavior with Abe’s direct requests to meet with Xi later this year at the APEC summit in Beijing this November. Abe said at a press conference on Saturday that “If issues of concern exist, then dialogue should be held” and that the two countries should return to a “mutually beneficial relationship based on common strategic interests.” It would appear that for now Abe is still much more interested pursuing a stronger defense posture relative to China than seeking a path of mutual benefit. As his actions on collective self-defense are likely much more indicative of his true position on China, his pursuit of dialogue can be seen almost as an insurance policy. As Japan ratchets up its military capabilities and singles out China as the region’s premier threat, Abe will be able to point to several public and private attempts at dialogue with China that went unanswered, attempting to be the voice of reason should territorial disputes again take a turn for the worse.

Sign up for our weekly newsletter
The Diplomat Brief