Tokyo Notes

Ishihara: Japan Needs Nukes

Recent Features

Tokyo Notes

Ishihara: Japan Needs Nukes

Outspoken Tokyo Governor Shintaro Ishihara calls for Japan to build nuclear weapons to counter a rising China.

Tokyo’s outspoken Gov. Shintaro Ishihara says his country, which suffered history’s only nuclear attack, should build nuclear weapons to counter the threat from fast-rising China.

In my interview with Ishihara, published in The Independent today, Ishihara said Japan could develop nukes within a year and send a strong message to the world. ‘All our enemies: China, North Korea and Russia—all close neighbours—have nuclear weapons. Is there another country in the world in a similar situation?

‘People talk about the cost and other things, but the fact is that diplomatic bargaining power means nuclear weapons. All the members of the (United Nations) Security Council have them.’

Such comments, from the leader of Japan’s second-most powerful political office, come amid concerns about China’s growing military muscle. Beijing announced last week that its 2011 defense budget will be boosted by 12.7 percent to $91.5 billion, up from $81 billion last year. And most experts say that those figures are an underestimate.

China officially overtook Japan as the world’s second-largest economy last month. Despite booming bilateral trade, the relationship has regularly been shaken by disputes over territorial and historical issues. Ties are still struggling to recover from a maritime clash last year over the Senkaku Islands, which are administered by Japan but claimed by China.

Ishihara said the clash, which ended when police released the captain of a Chinese ship accused of ramming Japan’s coastguard vessels, exposed his country’s weakness in Asia. ‘China wouldn’t have dared laid a hand on the Senkakus (if Japan had nuclear weapons).’ The governor added that a nuclear-armed Japan would also win more respect from Russia, which seized four Japanese-owned islands at the end of World War II.  And he advised his constitutionally pacifist nation to scrap restrictions on the manufacture and sale of weapons. ‘We should develop sophisticated (yuushuu na) weapons and sell them abroad. Japan made the best tanks in the world before America crushed the industry. We could get that back.’

Ishihara’s right-wing politics and persistent warnings about the rise of China have earned him the sobriquet ‘Japan’s Jean-Marie Le Pen.’ But there are signs that the national consensus has moved closer to his brand of nationalist politics since he took office in 1999.  A stunning 78 percent of respondents in the last annual survey on Japanese attitudes toward China said they did ‘not feel friendly’ towards their neighbour, the highest rating since the poll began in 1978.

Conservatives have long demanded that Tokyo ditch its postwar Constitution, which was written during the American occupation of the country and renounces war as a sovereign right. Japan’s so-called non-nuclear principles, produced during the long reign of Prime Minister Minister Eisaku Sato 1964-72, later committed the country to never produce, possess or allow the entry of nuclear weapons. The principles were partly a response to popular revulsion over the deaths of over quarter of a million people, mostly civilians, in the 1945 US bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

Ishihara claims that Sato, who won the 1974 Nobel Peace Prize for his opposition to plans for a nuclear-weapons programme, was at the same time secretly approaching the United States for help in developing an atomic bomb. ‘Japan asked the US (Lyndon B.) Johnson administration for help in developing nuclear weapons but America refused. If the Sato administration had unilaterally developed weapons then, for a start North Korea wouldn’t have taken so many of our citizens,’ he said, referring to Pyongyang’s abduction of an unknown number of Japanese people.

Sato had in any case undermined the no-nuke rule by striking a backroom deal with Washington, signed with then-President Richard Nixon in 1969.  The pact allowed nuclear-armed US ships and aircraft to traffic anywhere through or over Japanese territory and was confirmed by a senior Japanese Foreign Ministry bureaucrat in 2009.

Ishihara also suggested that US President Barack Obama’s 2009 pledge to rid the world of nuclear weapons wasn't genuine.  ‘Obama said “yes we can” when he promised to abolish nuclear weapons, then followed it with “but we don’t.” The US is still making computer simulations of new weapons. Japan should do the same,’ he said.

He added that Japan’s unique history gives it more reason than most to change its non-nuclear stance. ‘Japan is the only country with legitimate reason to hold nuclear weapons because it was the only country attacked by nuclear weapons,’ he said. ‘I have a good journalist friend in Washington and he heard (former US Secretary of State Henry) Kissinger say off record: "We want Japan to have nukes. If Japan had nukes, it would be a favourable era for America." I agree with that.’

’All our enemies: China, North Korea and Russia—all close neighbours have nukes. One kidnaps hundreds of our people. Another snatched the Northern Territories from us after the war. And another lays claims to our island (The Senkakus).  In this day and age is there any other country in the world in a similar situation? The people of this country are very uneasy about what’s going on.’

Ishihara is expected to step down this year after 12 years governing the capital of 13 million people, though he’s not obliged to declare his candidacy until March 11, the final session of the city’s government. His term in office has been marked by a string of controversial bon mots and often harsh criticism of his political contemporaries. In his latest interview, Ishihara called former Prime Minister Hatoyama Yukio ‘an idiot’ for pinning his diplomatic strategy toward Beijing on the philosophy of yuai, or ‘fraternity.’

‘Of course all countries prefer to be friends with other countries. But Hatoyama was an idiot. He didn’t understand power politics.  He’s just a sentimentalist. There’s no point in even discussing him. It’s a sign of Japan’s weakness that he was elected.’