Last month, Iran reached a landmark nuclear agreement with the P5+1. Speculation soon followed that the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline would benefit from the nuclear deal. The Economic Times meanwhile reported that India was “set to push for the proposed $7 billion gas pipeline from Iran via Pakistan,” now that restrictions were likely to ease in the wake of the nuclear deal.
However, the U.S. State Department said recently that sanctions on the Iran pipeline project still existed. A spokesperson also told reporters that, “We don’t consider Iran open for business yet, and there’s no new sanctions relief beyond the very limited relief under the joint plan of action that’s been in place since January 2014.” He added, “When Iran meets its key nuclear steps and we get to implementation day, then there will be commensurate relief of nuclear-related sanctions.”
According to one Islamabad-based analyst, who spoke with The Diplomat on condition of anonymity, Washington’s clarification reflects its opposition to the pipeline project. That is a position backed by recent media reports, which have Russia and China both interested in the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline, with the U.S. opposed.
Those positions are part of broader regional trends, which have seen the U.S. and India draw closer, and Pakistan turn towards Russia. For example, when U.S. President Barack Obama visited New Delhi in January 2015, Indian defense analyst Ajai Shukla told Al Jazeera that, “The trip basically means that the post-Cold War situation has been re-ordered and crystallized, and given the emerging rivalry between America and China, the U.S. has decided that India is a crucial swing state that needs to be cultivated as a close security and economic partner, as a representative of U.S. interests in South Asia.”
Meanwhile, Moscow – which has historically had closer relations with India, Pakistan’s neighbor and great rival – is increasingly orienting toward Islamabad, as New Delhi and Washington become cozy. Yury Barmin, an analyst specializing in Russia’s Middle East policy, said that Moscow was using the pipeline to get closer to Pakistan and show India it had other options in the region. For his part, Chinese President Xi Jinping recently visited Islamabad, where he announced energy and infrastructure projects worth $46 billion, the biggest ever investment in Pakistan.
The U.S. favors the Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India (TAPI) pipeline, which happens to be opposed by Russia. Syed Fazl-e-Haider, a development analyst based in Pakistan, has noted that U.S. opposition to the Iran-Pakistan reflects its desire to get Caspian resources to world markets through a safer, shorter route, which in Washington’s eyes meant traversing Afghan territory. But the project has to date foundered on the security situation in Afghanistan. Still, when a Turkmenistan delegation met with Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif in Islamabad recently, officials told media representatives that construction on the TAPI gas pipeline project is to begin in December.
‘Crossing Half of Balochistan’
Renowned Pakistani journalist Ahmed Rashid points to another factor in dealing with Iran: security. In a recent interview, he said, “To my mind, the major thing in this whole pipeline business is the security in Pakistan itself. You’re crossing half of Balochistan which has got an insurgency; you cannot expect people to build a pipeline and all.” He went on to add, “It is not good enough to say we would crush the Baloch. We have been trying it for ten years and not been able to do that. So you should talk to the Baloch and give them a heavy chunk of the benefits of this deal.”
Shehzad Baloch, a Quetta-based analyst, pointed out to The Diplomat that though the IP gas pipeline is significant, Pakistan has yet to construct its section, unlike Iran, which has completed its part of the work. He believes that Pakistan’s government is unlikely to get serious about the pipeline, noting that Balochistan, Pakistan’s largest province, has never been a priority. The analyst said that Iran wants to supply electricity to Balochistan to put an end to electricity crisis in the province, but the Punjab bureaucracy has for years shown little interest.
Baloch added that if the pipeline project were to be completed it could bring huge economic changes to Pakistan. But Balochistan could well miss out, as it has little or almost no say in the deal.
Nonetheless, in the wake of the nuclear accord, Pakistani officials seem optimist. Minister of Petroleum and Natural Resources Shahid Khaqan Abbasi told reporters that with sanctions removed, Pakistan will be able to address its energy needs and meet its contractual obligations, adding: “Projects worth Rs 1,000 billion are underway for completion of Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline and LNG smart gas projects.”
Adnan Aamir, a columnist with The News International, tells The Diplomat that he does not see the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline project becoming a reality anytime soon. He notes that even if economic sections are in Iran are finally lifted, Saudi pressure on Pakistan to abandon the project remains.
“The construction of pipelines under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) and TAPI have reduced the significance of the Iran-Pakistan gas project for Pakistan. Now Pakistan cannot afford to earn the ire of Saudi Arabia for IP project when it can get gas from elsewhere.”
The author is a columnist at the Daily Times. Visit his blog or follow him on Twitter @Akbar_notezai. He can be reached at [email protected].