The Pulse

South Asian Leaders Meet on Sidelines of Paris Climate Talks

The leaders of Afghanistan and India met separately with the Pakistani Prime Minister, not much happened.

South Asian Leaders Meet on Sidelines of Paris Climate Talks
Credit: Asianet-Pakistan /

The Paris climate talks currently underway have provided an ample opportunity for world leaders to meet along the sidelines (or not, in the case of Putin and Erdogan). South Asian leaders from Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India have taken advantage of the timing, even if they are unlikely to make any measurable degree of progress on important and intractable issues.

Monday, Afghan President Ashraf Ghani and Pakistani President Nawaz Sharif met and discussed the possibility of resuming peace talks. The two were joined by British Prime Minister David Cameron, according to Pakistani media and a VOA article published ahead of the talks. Cameron had met with Sharif on November 27 during the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) on the island of Malta. According to the Pakistani Prime Minister’s office, during their bilateral discussion there Sharif “emphasized Pakistan’s readiness to play its constructive role in facilitating the peace and reconciliation process in Afghanistan, because Pakistan strongly believes in peace and stability of the entire region.”

The Afghan side hasn’t said much, but the Pakistanis released a statement saying that “Both leaders agreed to work with all those who would enter such a process as legitimate political actors and act, alongside the Afghan government, against those who refuse to take the path of peace.”

After this summer’s abortive peace talks, Ghani’s attempts to rebuild Afghanistan’s relationship with Pakistan stalled. As Ankit Panda wrote recently, “Ghani’s misguided attempt to forge a workable relationship with Pakistan cost India and Afghanistan a ‘lost year’ that could have otherwise seen real strategic progress.” Panda points to the fact that Afghanistan and India have renewed arms trades–specifically four attack helicopters–as evidence that Kabul may be moving on. Pakistan, however, can’t really be left out of the pursuit of negotiated peace in the region. Afghanistan views Pakistan as the key to pushing the Pakistan-based Taliban leadership to the table.

Sharif also met with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday. Not much has been reported as to what was discussed. Sharif told Pakistani media that “Pakistan desires better bilateral relations with India.” As the Wall Street Journal’s Niharika Mandhana pointed out, recent attempts to ameliorate the tensions inherent in the India-Pakistan relationship have been unsuccessful. The two countries’ national security advisors were to meet in August, but the meeting was canceled over disagreements as to what would be discussed. Modi and Sharif passed on the opportunity to meet during the UN General Assembly in September.

Both India and Afghanistan seem skeptical about Pakistan’s advances. Nothing said–that has ben reported so far–is new or different. It’s going to take more than a few minutes talking on a couch in Paris to patch up regional relations.