The Pulse

Sri Lanka Faces a Human Rights Curveball from China

China made an unexpected comment about Sri Lanka’s human rights record. What does that really mean?

Sri Lanka Faces a Human Rights Curveball from China
Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Sri Lanka recently wrapped up the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) 2013 amid much controversy. Despite the the prestige of being selected as the venue for the meeting, Mahinda Rajapaksa, the Sri Lankan president, was assailed from across the Commonwealth for his country’s poor human rights record. The UK’s David Cameron, Canada’s Stephen Harper, and neighboring India’s Manmohan Singh all faced immense domestic pressure over the meeting because their attendance would have been perceived as a tacit acknowledgement that Sri Lanka’s poor human rights record is irrelevant. Harper and Singh ultimately did not themselves attend the meeting.

However, in a somewhat novel and unexpected development, China came out last week and called on Sri Lanka to “make efforts to protect and promote human rights.” Qin Gang, a spokesperson for the Chinese Foreign Ministry, told reporters that “This is an issue within the Commonwealth, but at the same time I believe that on the human rights issue, dialogue and communication should be enhanced among countries.”

This rhetoric from the Chinese is a fundamental departure from their earlier support for Rajapaksa’s government. According to The Hinduthe Chinese  “when asked about international criticism aimed at Sri Lanka in the lead-up to a United States-backed resolution at the U.N. Human Rights Council, … lauded Mahinda Rajapaksa’s government for making ‘great strides’ in promoting human rights.” China also stated that Sri Lanka’s internal affairs should be left to Sri Lankans.

Has China’s acquisition of a seat at the UN human rights council earlier this month made it more interested in speaking out in this way? Probably not. In fact, Qin Gang’s statement continued to include the following qualifier: “Due to differences in economic and social development of different countries, there could be differences on human rights protection. So what is important is that the relevant country should make efforts to protect and promote human rights, while other countries in the world should provide constructive assistance.”

This seems consistent with expert perceptions of China’s human rights policy. A Human Rights Watch report from 2011 notes that “main concern at the [human rights council] appears to be to protect state sovereignty from what it considers undue interference in domestic affairs through overly critical resolutions.” The statement could also reflect China’s desire to be seen as a responsible great power in Asia — it is known to periodically make its commitment to international norms known through public statements.

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

Nevertheless, the statement must come as somewhat of a surprise for Sri Lanka, which has cooperated with China extensively in fomenting its own economic development. Reports indicate that after the three-decade long civil war came to a close in 2009, China was quick to reap the benefits of political stability by immediately emerging as Sri Lanka’s largest creditor. China loaned the island state $1.2 billion — more than India — as it attempted to make major strategic inroads with Rajapaksa. Future investment inflow is expected to exceed $4 billion.

As I’ve written before, India missed an important opportunity with CHOGM 2013 to make inroads with Sri Lanka bilaterally and establish itself as a regional leader. Concern over China’s influence in Sri Lanka has recently risen to the top of the agenda for the Indian strategic community — the relationship is perceived as one of the most threatening nodes in China’s so-called “String of Pearls” strategy. Indeed, certain strategists will point out that China’s support for Sri Lanka saw a major uptick in 2012 after its Defense Secretary Gotabaya Rajapaksa visited Beijing to discuss military cooperation and strategic ties with then-Chinese Minister of National Defense Liang Guanglie.

As for Sri Lanka, the Chinese statement on its human rights record is sure to cause some discomfort. China has been a valuable partner for the small nation in multilateral fora over the human rights question, and doubting its support now could be destabilizing to the bilateral relationship. Sri Lanka will face a U.S. sponsored resolution on its human rights violations at the next UNHRC session, expected to take place in March 2014.